Tevatron BPM Requirements Review

Committee Report
Management Closeout

Addendum: Comments from Reviewers


First Part of the milestone review for WBS 1.3.4.6.4.2.
**There is no plnned meeting for this review at this time.  It would be an 
editorial process where the reviewers read the document and send comments
and/or questions to the Committee Chair and the Review Manager.** 
The reviewers are requested to respond by September 17, 2003.

Document being reviewed:

Tevatron Beam Position Monitor Upgrade Requirements

Goal:

To review the measurement requirements for the proposed BPM upgrade. Upon approval, the project will advance to the technical design phase.

Review Committee:

Don Edwards (Chair)
Alan Baumbaugh
Mike Church
Mike Harrison (BNL)
John Marriner
Dave McGinnis
Mike Syphers

Charge:

  1. Are the requirements described in the document adequate for the needs of Run II as they are perceived today and as they may evolve?. There is no doubt about the need for measurement accuracy beyond the current 0.15 mm limit of the existing anolog to digintal converters, and we can probably agree that 20 micrometer level is reasonable. Or do we?
  2. Are we paying adequate attention to the distant future? The present system is 20 years old, and the Tevatron must survive for at least another couple of decades.

Committee Report

Comments from committee members:
Comments from Alan Baumbaugh
Comments from Mike Church
Comments from Mike Harrison
Comments from John Marriner

Tevatron BPM Project Web Page


Contact: Pushpa Bhat

Security, Privacy, Legal